Description
Instructions: Search for scholarly journal articles using Google Scholar and Carleton’s Omni catalog. Then select two sources tied to your topic in assignment one.
So this assignment is linked to the first one you did. I will link the finished assignment that you did because they are related to each other. I will also share the feedback for the first assignment in order to see where the mistakes happened.
I will attach the assignment pdf instructions along with a rough template and some other citation instructions. Please let me know if you have any questions and make sure all work is 100% plagiarism free and AI free since it will be run through multiple machines.
Below is the feedback for assignment 1 that you also did 🙂
Assignment 1 was the “Find credible sources assignment” completed by you.
“Thank you for your work! You chose a very interesting topic, and narrowed it down through your search, which is great! Your assignment is missing in-text citations. Please review the assignment guidelines and the APA citation crash course on BrightSpace. We were expecting you’d reference the publishers in question 2 for example. Moreover, while you do reference the CRAAP criteria, your analysis is surface level. For example, the “currency” criterion is not just in reference to the date of the news article publication. It is also about the currency of the links and sources the journalist draws from. Again, you did not cite the CRAAP test as a resource in this answer either. As for your answers more broadly, you did great! Your search process is clearly outlined and makes sense. You clearly understand what peer-review means and why it is important for your research. The sources you chose were interesting. Overall, good work! I look forward to reading more of your work as you continue exploring and narrowing down this topic further.”
Links:
Google scholar
https://scholar.google.com
https://library.carleton.ca
Unformatted Attachment Preview
0
Source Analysis
Sana Al-Barakat
101122437
Coms 2004
Prof. Emily Hiltz
TA Aseel Qazzaz
October 2,2023
1
The Sources
Book-Earl, J., & Rohlinger, D. A. (Eds.). (2017). Social movements and media. Emerald
Publishing Limited.https://doi.org/10.1108/S2050-206020170000014013.
News Article-Pearce, M. (2022, August 16). American media wants to save democracy. Is
it helping? Los Angeles Times. https://www.latimes.com/entertainment-arts/story/202207-29/la-ent-american-media-democracy
Scholarly Journal Article-Şener, G., Yücel, H., & Yedikardeş, U. (2019). Youth and
Party Politics in Digital Era: Social Media Practices of Young Members of Political Parties
in Turkey. Global Media Journal (İstanbul), 10(19), 1–
.http://globalmediajournaltr.yeditepe.edu.tr/sites/default/files/01_gulum_sener_hakan_yuce
l_umur_yedikardes.pdf
Source Credibility Analysis
Question 1: Explaining the topic and search process
My initial topic choice was “Political movements and mass media,” emphasizing young
people. I began by using the library’s search feature and combining keywords and Boolean
search techniques. My main search terms were “Political movements,” “mass media,” and
“Youths.” In order to ensure that all three terms were contained in the sources, I used the
Boolean operator “AND” to whittle down the results. The original search produced many results,
demonstrating the topic’s vast range. I decided to concentrate on the connection between youth
media use and political activism to sharpen my focus. I focused on “Youth involvement in
political movements through mass media.” In order to do this more focused search, I changed
2
my terms. I included terms like “Youth political participation,” “Media influence on youths in
politics,” and “Youth engagement in political movements.” This made it easier to find sources
that dealt, especially with how young people participated in political movements mediated by the
media. I used the library catalog’s search filters to locate the needed sources. I used the peerreviewed sources filter to narrow my choices for the scholarly journal article. I chose one point
of focus: “Youth and Party Politics in the Digital Era: Social Media Practices of Young Members
of Political Parties.” I went to the news area and picked a recent story from the Los Angeles
Times titled “American media wants to save democracy. Is it helping?” for the news article.
Finally, I performed a separate search for the book using the keywords “Social movements and
media,” leading me to a book titled “Social Movements and Media,” edited by J. Earl and D.A.
Rohlinger, which provided comprehensive insights into the topic.
Question 2: Confirming types of sources
The three sources I selected for my assignment encompass diverse perspectives on the
intersection of political movements and mass media. The sources also have a particular emphasis
on youth involvement. The scholarly journal article is one of the reliable sources. It was
published in the Global Media Journal (Istanbul), specifically in Volume 10, Issue 19, spanning
pages 1-13. To substantiate its scholarly nature, I examined the Global Media Journal (Istanbul)
official website. This helped to authenticate its academic standing. The source is also credible
because it is peer-reviewed. A peer review is where other reliable experts review the research
article to ensure it reflects the truth (O’Neil et al., 2022). Moreover, the authors’ affiliations with
academic institutions further confirmed the scholarly credibility of the work. The authors are
well-qualified individuals who have the authority in this field. They are qualified experts who
can offer reliable insights on the topic. The journal is also other sources which shows that it has
3
been used to inform other research endeavours. The fact that other researchers on the field trust
shows that it can be relied on. The news article was published in the Los Angeles Times on
August 16, 2022, showing that it is a reliable source. The article’s authenticity was assured when
accessed via the Los Angeles Times’ official website. I also double-checked the author’s
credentials and discovered that Michael Pearce was affiliated with the Los Angeles Times. The
book was written by J. Earl and D.A. Rohlinger and released by Emerald Publishing Limited,
provided a thorough investigation of the topic. I carefully examined the book information to
confirm that it was published as a book. Emerald Publishing Limited, a well-regarded company
recognized for producing academic works, published it. Multiple book retailers’ websites and
library catalogs also listed this work as a book, further reinforcing its status. The author is also an
expert in this field with much experience. An International Standard Book Number (ISBN) also
confirmed its categorization as a book. This shows that the book is reliable and that its
information can help research the topic.
Question 3: Assessing the credibility of the news source
After subjecting the news source to the CRAAP Test criteria, I believe it to be reliable.
Since the article was published in August 2022, it satisfies the “currency” requirement since it is
current and pertinent to the ongoing discussion about the role of media in democracy. Regarding
“relevance,” the paper immediately addresses a significant issue regarding the efficiency of
American media in upholding democracy, which is consistent with the subject of my research.
The Los Angeles Times is a reputable news source with a long history of distributing accurate
information, so the “Authority” requirement is satisfied. The author further increases the report’s
legitimacy; Michael Pearce is a well-known journalist who works for the Los Angeles Times.
The article presents several points of view on the subject while providing factual information,
4
which is what ” Accuracy ” means. It does not have any glaring mistakes or false information.
Finally, the “Purpose” requirement is satisfied because the article aims to inform and analyze
rather than advance a particular viewpoint or agenda. It presents a fair analysis of how the media
affects democracy. The article offers several viewpoints without displaying any blatant
prejudice. I believe the chosen news source from the Los Angeles Times to be credible based on
the results of the CRAAP Test. It satisfies all the requirements listed in the CRAAP Test rubric
and demonstrates currency, relevance, authority, correctness, and purposefulness. This
assessment reinforces my confidence in the article’s reliability and suitability for inclusion in my
research on political movements and mass media, particularly in democracy preservation. The
Los Angeles Times is also a reputable and longstanding news organization, adding credibility to
the article. Michael Pearce is also an established journalist, thus providing a balanced analysis of
the media’s role in democracy, enhancing the article’s credibility. The fact that the news article is
current, written by credible journalist and published by a reliable press company makes it a good
source.
References
Earl, J., & Rohlinger, D. A. (Eds.). (2017). Social movements and media. Emerald Publishing
Limited.https://doi.org/10.1108/S2050-206020170000014013.
5
O’Neil, J., Eisenmann, M., & Holman, M. (2022). A mixed methods examination of how people
assess the credibility of sources used by public relations practitioners. Journal of Promotion
Management, 26(1), 75-96.https://doi.org/10.1080/10496491.2018.1536619
Pearce, M. (2022, August 16). American media wants to save democracy. Is it helping? Los
Angeles Times. https://www.latimes.com/entertainment-arts/story/2022-07-29/la-entamerican-media-democracy
Şener, G., Yücel, H., & Yedikardeş, U. (2019). Youth and Party Politics in Digital Era: Social
Media Practices of Young Members of Political Parties in Turkey. Global Media Journal
(İstanbul), 10(19), 1–
.http://globalmediajournaltr.yeditepe.edu.tr/sites/default/files/01_gulum_sener_hakan_yuce
l_umur_yedikardes.pdf
Prof. Emily Hiltz, COMS 2004A Fall 2023
COMS 2004A – Assignment two: Reading and Discussing Literature Reviews
Due: Oct. 19 (Oct. 20) if using the automatic extension option)
Objective: Students will learn how to access and use scholarly literature review
sections of journal articles as part of their ongoing research on a COMS-related topic.
Instructions: Search for scholarly journal articles using Google Scholar and
Carleton’s Omni catalog. Select two sources tied to your topic in assignment one.
Answer the questions below. A paper template is available here.
Formatting: Please include a title page following APA style and double-space your
paper, use 12-point font, Times New Roman. An introduction or conclusion is not
needed for this assignment, and you may use ‘I.’ Save your file as a Word file (.docx).
——————————————————————————————————————–Key Questions to ask in reading and reviewing the selected scholarly sources:
1) Finding Sources: Which two journal articles did you select and how did you find
them? What are their topics and arguments?
Introduce each source and provide a short summary of the topics and arguments the
scholars make in each journal article. Explain how you searched for the sources using
both Omni and Google Scholar. Provide details so someone could replicate your search.
*Approx. answer length: 250-350 words
2) Consulting the authors’ literature reviews: What literature (existing scholarship)
did the authors consult?
Refer to the literature review sections of both articles. If there isn’t a designated literature
section, see parts of the work that refer to other scholarly sources.
What literature or secondary sources do the authors review for their research?
Describe the literature that was consulted by referring to particular disciplines, concepts,
and other scholars that the authors refer to. Please include evidence from the sources
(and cite) to illustrate. *Approx. answer length: 250 words.
3) Reflection: In general, what is the purpose of researchers reviewing literature?
More specifically, in your selected articles, how did the researchers’ review of the
literature shape their work?
Refer to relevant lecture and reading material regarding the purpose of literature
reviews. Refer to evidence from your selected articles to show how the scholars used
the literature to inform their own research practices. Answer: 250-350 words.
Title of Your Assignment: Subtitle If You Have One
Student Name
School of Journalism & Communication, Carleton University
COMS 2004A: Introduction to Communication Research
Prof. Emily Hiltz
TA Name:
Date submitted:
Question 1: Summarizing both sources, explaining the search process
Insert your answer here in complete sentences.
Question 2: Literature the authors consulted
Insert your answer here in complete sentences.
Question 3: How the authors’ literature review shaped their research
Insert your answer here in complete sentences.
1
References
2
How to cite a citation
Some tips!
COMS 2004A – by Grace Goldbaum, Aseel Qazzaz & Emily Hiltz
Step by Step Tips:
• Step 1: The author of your selected article that you’ve chosen is Author A
E.g., Jiwani, 2021
• Step 2: The in-text cited work in Author A’s scholarly article is Author B
E.g., In Jiwani’s (2021) article, she refers to Chao’s (2015) research
• Step 3: To cite other sources that are cited in your article by Author A, use the
following in-text citation: (Author B, Year, as cited in Author A, Year, p. #)
E.g., (Chao 2015, as cited in Jiwani, 2021, p. 54)
• Step 4: Author A’s article must be listed in your reference list*
E.g., Jiwani, Y. (2021). Gendered Islamophobia in the Case of the Returning ISIS
Women: A Canadian Narrative. Islamophobia Studies Journal, 6 (1): 52-77.
*A reminder that two scholarly journal articles are required for this paper. The second article
should also appear in your reference list.
Another example of using indirect citations:
• “For example, suppose you are reading an article by Brown (2014) that cites information from an
article by Snow (1982) that you would like to include in your essay.
For the Reference list, you will only make a citation for the secondary source (Brown). You
do not put in a citation for the primary source (Snow) in the Reference list.
For the in-text citation, you identify the primary source (Snow) and then write “as cited in”
the secondary source (Brown). If you know the year of the publication of the primary source,
include it in the in-text citation. Otherwise, you can omit it. See below for examples.
• According to a study by Snow (1982, as cited in Brown, 2014), 75% of students believe that
teachers should not assign nightly homework.”
From: https://libguides.capilanou.ca/apa/secondary_citation
Purchase answer to see full
attachment
