Description
You would read 5 articles relating to postpartum depression and exercise and create an evidence table following the rubrics, be sure to arrange the table and references alphabetically in an APA format in a consize manner answering the question specifically.
Unformatted Attachment Preview
1
Evidence
Table:
Use
JHNEBP
Evidence
Rating
Scales
2
Sources
Part 2 – Evidence Table
Each student is responsible for reviewing 5 research articles relevant to their PICOT.
Excellent
Good
Fair
Poor
9-10 points
7-8 points
4-6 points
0-3 points
Score
Table is clear and easily
Table is neat and legible.
Table contains layout or
Source information is not
/10
legible. Comparison of data
Appropriately cited. Literature legibility errors.
organized in table format.
logical. Appropriately cited.
review results listed
Literature review results Literature review results
Well organized literature
highlighting the studies which
listed highlighting the
listed are incomplete
review results highlighting the best exemplify the PICOT
studies which best
and/or do not include the
studies which best exemplify problem. Include most
exemplify the PICOT
studies which best
the PICOT problem. Has a
elements needed to evaluate
problem. Include some
exemplify the PICOT
minimum of 5 peer reviewed the quality and strength of
elements needed to
problem. Include few or no
articles. Include all elements
findings. Correctly rates
evaluate the quality and elements needed to
needed to evaluate the quality strength and quality of at least strength of findings.
evaluate the quality and
and strength of findings.
3 studies according to the
Correctly rates strength
strength of findings.
Correctly rates strength and
JHNEBP Evidence Rating Scales. and quality of at least 2
Incorrectly rates strength
quality of articles according to Follows APA guidelines as
studies according to the
and quality of all studies
the JHNEBP Evidence Rating
appropriate.
JHNEBP Evidence Rating according to the JHNEBP
Scales. Follows APA guidelines
Scales. Inconsistently
Evidence Rating Scales.
as appropriate.
follows APA guidelines.
Does not follow APA
guidelines.
Evidence table includes
Complete and correct
Mostly (2/3) complete
All references are
/10
reference list and is formatted reference list using APA
and correct reference list incomplete and incorrectly
using APA Style. Studies are
formatting. Most of the
using APA formatting.
formatted. Most of the
current, 5 years or earlier, if
studies are current, 5 years or
Most of the studies are
studies are not current, 5
current literature is not
earlier, if current literature is
current, 5 years or
years or earlier, if current
available, no more than 10
not available, no more than 10 earlier, if current
literature is not available,
years. All 5 referenced articles years. All 5 referenced articles literature is not available, no more than 10 years. 1 or
are submitted with the table
are submitted with the table as no more than 10 years. 3 none of the 5 referenced
as a .pdf file.
a .pdf file.
out of 5 referenced
articles is submitted with
articles are submitted
the table as a .pdf file.
Restate PICOT question:
Author(s)
and year
Type of study
(design)
Population
characteristics &
sample size (n)
Independent
variable
Dependent
variable
Results
Evidence Strength &
Quality Rating
(JHNEBP)
Restate PICOT question: Are non-pharmacological interventions more effective in managing chemotherapy side effects than
pharmacological interventions in breast cancer patients during treatment?
Author(s) and Type of study
year
(design)
Population
Independent
characteristics &
variable
sample size (n)
Zachariae, R., A randomized Participants were
Internet
Amidi, A.,
controlled
225 Danish
cognitive
Damholdt, M.
trial
breast cancer
behavioral
F.,
survivors age
therapy for
Clausen, C. D.
from 18 to 75
insomnia
, Dahlgaard, J.,
years old with
(iCBT-I) or no
Lord, H., …
significant
iCBT-I therapy
Ritterband, L.
insomnia were
as control.
M. (2018).
recruited
between 2011 to
2013. The
participants were
randomized into
iCBT-I group
(n=133) or
control group
(n=122).
Heckler, C. E., A randomized Of 96 cancer
Cognitive
Garland, S. N., controlled
survivors with
Behavioral
Peoples, A. R., trial
chronic insomnia
Therapy for
Perlis, M. L.,
were recruited
Insomnia
Shayne, M.,
between 2008 to
(CBT-I) or
Morrow, G. R.
2012. They were
control.
,…
randomly assigned
Roscoe, J. A.
to CBT-I +
(2015)
placebo
Dependen
t variable
Sleep
outcomes
and
Fatigue.
Brief
Fatigue
Inventory
(BFI),
Functional
Assessme
nt of
Chronic
Illness
Results
Evidence Strength & Quality
Rating
(JHNEBP)
Insomnia severity,
This is a Level I, quality A
impaired sleep quality, and
research.
sleep efficiency were
A randomized controlled trial is
significant improved by 9
the highest level of research to
weeks of intervention if
find the causal relationship
compared with the control
between intervention and
(p
Purchase answer to see full
attachment
